The Trans Agenda #10
[15 March 2024]
Welcome to The Trans Agenda, a newsletter that will arrive in your inbox Monday to Friday if you are subscribed. You can also read it on Substack and on Trans Writes.
Publications known for taking an anti-trans stance are and will be referenced and linked. Often, these are the most comprehensive sources for these stories because of their obsession with trans people. I give a summary for those stories so you can make the choice if you want to click the link or seek out more information elsewhere.
TL;DR
- Washington transgender woman murdered, body found in Mexico.
- Council of Europe release report on disparity between legal recognition and reality of discrimination and violence faced by trans people.
- Trans ‘activists’ and Gender Critical ‘campaigners’ are excluded from the new definition of ‘extremism’.
- Transgender scientists highlight academia challenges, seek support.
- Liz Truss’s anti-trans Private Member’s Bill is up for its second reading.
- MPs award themselves another payrise.
- Rishi Sunak rules out 2 May election.
- Government place another Tory on the BBC Board.
- UK media ignore JK Rowling.
- LGBT has got a T in there for a reason – trans people started our movement.
- ITV’s political editor Robert Peston was spotted having lunch with Liz Truss.
- Liz Truss accepted £20k trip to US right-wing event attended by Jordan Peterson.
- Joe Biden tweets statement on Nex Benedict.
- Paper review.
- Jobs and opportunities.
- plus more…
NEWS & POLITICS
Human rights of trans people: increased visibility and legal recognition contrast with lived experience of discrimination, violence [Commissioner for Human Rights]
- A report, titled “Human Rights and Gender Identity and Expression”, by the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights, highlights advancements in the recognition and protection of the rights of transgender people in Europe but leaves no doubt when it comes to how bad the situation is.
It revisits and updates a landmark 2009 Issue Paper, reflecting changes over the past 15 years in the legal, social, and human rights landscapes.
Despite advances, it acknowledges trans people continue to face high levels of discrimination, violence, and insecurity and it is not shy about pointing these out. Legal protection and recognition remain uneven across Europe, with some countries showing signs of regression. This is occurring in a broader context where marginalised groups are increasingly weaponised for political gain, and anti-gender movements are gaining traction, undermining the rights of everyone, particularly trans people. The report calls countries out.
The report also offers recommendations, most of which boil down to ‘stop being dicks to trans people and let them live their lives without your involvement’. The Gender Critical Sex Realists will not like one single word of it.
It is a comprehensive report covering Equality and non-discrimination, Gender identity and gender expression conversion practices, Legal gender recognition, Violence, hate crimes and hate speech, Detention, Family life, Education, Sport, Employment, Poverty and housing, Healthcare, Sanitation, Asylum as well as Gender identity and broader opposition to human rights.
You can read the full report here.
Trans ‘activists’ and Gender Critical ‘campaigners’ are excluded from the new definition of ‘extremism’
- Michael Gove had to carve out a hole in his new extremism definition to make sure that people who hold extremist views, like gender critical sex realists, didn’t get caught up in it. While the people calling for the removal of rights from trans people are still called ‘campaigners’ trans people are referred to as ‘activists’ just for existing.
Gove told the House of Commons on Thursday, “Our definition will not affect gender-critical campaigners, those with conservative religious beliefs, trans activists, environmental protest groups, or those exercising their proper right to free speech. The government is taking every possible precaution to strike a balance in drawing up the new definition between protecting fundamental rights and safeguarding citizens.”
This is clearly a lie, as protecting the rights in this regard of gender critical sex realists clearly impacts the fundamental rights of trans people to live equally and without harassment. I’m not sure how you can read the criteria below and not know in your brain, gut and heart that they fit 1 and 3.
Here is what the government said, “Extremism is the promotion or advancement of an ideology based on violence, hatred or intolerance, that aims to:
1. negate or destroy the fundamental rights and freedoms of others; or
2. undermine, overturn or replace the UK’s system of liberal parliamentary democracy and democratic rights; or
3. intentionally create a permissive environment for others to achieve the results in (1) or (2).”Anti-trans activist MP Miriam Cates has already expressed her concerns that her pals ‘could’ fall under the definition, but Gove reassured her that there was nothing in this plan that would lead to the silencing of individuals.
Labour offered no opposition of substance. Conservative peer Sayeeda Warsi called the new definition ‘authoritarian’.
Trans scientists highlight academia challenges, seek support [Cell]
- In a landmark commentary in Cell, 24 trans scientists and their family members address the challenges faced by trans people in STEMM fields. They discuss the historical roots of trans marginalisation and its impact on careers in science and medicine, advocating for support for trans colleagues. Highlighting the importance of community and resistance against anti-trans legislation, the authors argue for more inclusive environments that respect all forms of gender expression. They suggest practical steps for cisgender individuals and institutions to foster inclusivity and equity, emphasising the collective benefit of these actions for the entire scientific community.
New Frank Hester donation waiting to be declared [Politico Playbook PM]
- To make matters worse, Frank Hester has handed another £5 million to the Tories, a donation which is waiting to be declared in the next donations update. For more on Frank Hester and his comments about Diane Abbott, see Trans Agenda #9 and #8.
MPs award themselves another payrise
- MPs pay is set to exceed £90k-per-year as they award themselves an above-inflation 5.5% payrise that will take effect from April. Remember, you vote for them so they can vote for themselves.
£91,346 is around three times the national average wage, much more if you live in Northern Ireland. While the UK median annual wage is £35,000, for those in the north of Ireland it is £32,900.
Rishi Sunak rules out 2 May election [Sky News]
- Just a day after I wrote a long piece explaining why I thought we would see Rishi Sunak go to the polls on 2 May [Trans Agenda #9], he decided to clarify to the nation that we won’t, in fact, be going to the polls for a general election that day. You’re welcome. Or sorry, as the case may be.
In response to the news, a few unnamed Labour politicians told Politico, “I know it sounds ridiculous but there is still a chance [it could be May],” said one. “We don’t believe him. And it could now be June or July, which doesn’t really change the timeline for us internally.” Another added, “I am old enough to remember when the Tories said over and over it wouldn’t be an election and then they called it anyway.”
Tory MP and former Minister Brandon Lewis will stand down at the next election
- That brings the number of Tories not seeking re-election to nearly 70.
Liz Truss accepted £20k trip to US right-wing event attended by Jordan Peterson [i]
- Liz Truss accepted a £20,000 trip to the US for a right-wing event, intensifying her ties with American conservatives. Attended by figures like Jordan Peterson, the conference aimed to “educate” political candidates on “how to dispel the lies of wokism, diversity equity and inclusion, ESG [environmental social and government], critical race theory and immigration”. Her actions, amidst efforts to revive her political career, are said to be causing concern within the UK government.
MEDIA & TODAY’S PAPERS
Government place another Tory on the BBC Board [UK Government]
- Former Theresa May Director of Communications and editorial adviser to GB News, Sir Robbie Gibb, has been re-appointed to the BBC Board by the government. It is a four-year appointment.
UK media ignore JK Rowling
- While media all over the world covered JK Rowling’s latest output on Twitter [Trans Agenda #9], the UK legacy media, who quote Rowling on a regular basis, found no space on their pages this time. Rowling, meanwhile, has won herself a new fan in Varg Vikernes, founder of neo Nazi organisation, Norwegian Heathen Front, who is also a convicted murderer and arsonist.
LGBT has got a T in there for a reason – trans people started our movement [Channel 4 News]
- Writer Armistead Maupin talks to Krishnan Guru-Murthy about transphobia in the UK and US, and why he’s using his voice to stand up for trans rights.
ITV’s political editor Robert Peston was spotted having lunch with Liz Truss [George Osborne]
Guardian and Mail spin new extremism definition differently
- In their Friday editions, The Guardian worry about LGBT campaigners being caught up along with Green campaigners while the Mail care about ‘feminists’ (Gender Critical Sex Realists) and Christians.
Daily Mail
- Tom Utley (who?) believes ‘our rulers’ have caught on to his wisdom about ‘wokery’. I’m fairly sure they’ve always been on the same page as Utley in backing these policies which are overwhelmingly unpopular with sane people.
Telegraph
- The Telegraph love putting ‘ideology’ after words they don’t like. They do it a lot in today’s edition, starting off going on about ‘Green ideology’ before wheeling out Allison Pearson to talk her usual brand of hateful shite. Telegraph columnists could and perhaps should fall under the government’s new definition of extremist.
HOUSE OF COMMONS
- The House of Commons will (possibly) debate Liz Truss’s Private Member’s Bill [Trans Agenda #7], ‘The Health & Equality Acts (Amendment) Bill’, which has little chance of passing but is being used to scare the crap out of trans people. If, by some miracle, Truss manages to secure a third reading for her bill, it will be eviscerated in the Lords. It’s listed third so there is a chance it won’t even get debated today. Ministers are prepared to back it now and amend later with an aide telling Playbook that “the bill “can support” Minister for Women and Equalities Kemi Badenoch but it’s “unworkable in its current form.””
- Labour MP Lloyd Russell-Moyle’s Private Member’s Bill, Conversion Practices (Prohibition) Bill, is also on the schedule after an adjourned debate on 1 March. In total, there are 33 Private Members’ Bills on the list, with 17 sponsored by Tory MP Christopher Chope.
HOUSE OF LORDS
- The House of Lords is not sitting.
SPORT
Council of Europe’s Human Rights Commissioner says ‘no evidence’ for anti-trans scaremongering in sport
- In the report linked above it says, “There is no evidence that trans women competitors are currently overrunning women’s sport, nor is there evidence that male fraudsters are systematically using trans rights for personal gain”.
It also says a lot more that’s worth reading.
AROUND THE WORLD
Washington transgender woman murdered, body found in Mexico [Imperial Valley Press]
- Reyna Hernandez, a 54-year-old trans woman from Renton, Washington, was reported missing on February 28th after failing to return home or open her business. Police investigations indicated she may have been taken against her will. Hernandez’s body was later discovered wrapped in a blanket in a cemetery in Mexicali, Mexico with evidence of a shotgun wound.
Mexican authorities identified Hernandez and arrested a 61-year-old Renton resident in connection with the case. Police believe this was a domestic violence crime. They are working with US federal partners to determine exactly where and when Hernandez was killed, with the goal of potentially extraditing the suspect if the crime occurred on US soil.
Joe Biden tweets statement on Nex Benedict [Joe Biden]
Despite saying he will ‘always have your backs’, it’s still not clear what Biden actually plans to do to protect trans people.
Balkan countries urged to do more on transgender rights [Balkan Insight]
- The Council of Europe’s Human Rights Commissioner has reported some progress in gender identity recognition across various Balkan countries. However, ‘issues’ like forced sterilisation and mental health diagnoses as conditions for legal gender recognition persist, clearly violating human rights on many levels.
How Delhi’s first Transgender rapper is bending rules with debut album [India West]
- Kinari, winner of the Toto Music Awards 2024, advocates for the LGBTQ+ community through her music, insisting it should make people dance and celebrate while being genuine. Despite facing challenges as a trans rapper in Delhi, Kinari remains dedicated to her music and is inspired by the changing landscape of artists. She plans a multi-city tour post-album release.
ANY OTHER BUSINESS
New study points the way for gay men to have babies using DNA from both partners [Queerty].
Court rules Japan’s ban on same-sex marriage is unconstitutional – again [Pink News].
The Washington Post report that 1,800 police officers were charged with child sexual abuse in the last 20 years [Washington Post].
- “Officers intentionally earned the trust of parents and guardians, created opportunities to get kids alone and threatened repercussions for broken silence. Unlike teachers and priests, they did it all while wielding the power of their badges and guns.”
Spanish lawmakers passed an amnesty for hundreds of Catalan separatists by 178 votes to 172, ending more than six months of negotiations which have paralysed parliament [Bloomberg].
Home Office officials have been told to get the first Rwanda deportation flight off the ground by the end of May [Telegraph].
Pro-Trump judge rejects bid by Donald Trump to throw out classified documents case on constitutional grounds [AP].
COMING UP
Friday
- Liz Truss’s anti-trans Private Member’s Bill second reading [see above]
- The Lib Dems spring conference starts in York tonight.
- Russia’s general election starts. There are four candidates running: Vladimir Putin, Vladislav Davankov, Leonid Slutsky, and Nikolay Kharitonov. If no one person receives more than half the vote, a second round of voting will take place exactly three weeks later.
Saturday
- Winner announced in Welsh Labour leadership election at 10am.
Sunday
- Russia’s ‘election’ winner will be announced.
- Ed Davey will give his keynote speech at the Lib Dem conference (11.45am).
JOBS & OPPORTUNITIES
Institute for Government
- Are looking for paid interns in what seems like a good opportunity. More details here.
Metro
- Looking for lifestyle freelancers to take on shifts in their London office. Email [email protected]
i newspaper
- Looking for a newsdesk editor for the late shift in London. More details here.
The Bitten Peach
- Queer Asian cabaret production company is on the lookout for a talented Social Media Manager to elevate their London/UK based queer Asian cabaret and nightlife production company’s social media. More details here.
Edinburgh International Book Festival
- Is looking for two trainee writers-in-residence. More details here.
Belfast Book Festival
- Has a call-out for all writers aged 18-26 living in Ireland to apply for “this extraordinary opportunity to attend and contribute to Belfast Book Festival 2024 as Young Writer Delegates.” More details here.
TRANSWRITES YOU MIGHT HAVE MISSED
- What does Liz Truss’s anti-trans bill actually say? By Lee Hurley.
- Understanding the “WPATH Files” debate, by Lee Hurley.
- JK Rowling will be arrested, finally, by Gemma Stone.
- Sex Matters Director Helen Joyce reads porn of teenagers for “research”, by Gemma Stone.
WEEKEND READING
- This moral panic about puberty blockers endangers the lives of trans kids, by Crystal [Metro]
- The Cass Review: Cis-supremacy in the UK’s approach to healthcare for trans children, by Cal Horton [Taylor & Francis Online]
- Why the Y chromosome is vanishing and what this means for the future, by Devika Rao [The Week]
- It wasn’t just the goblins — is J.K. Rowling doing Holocaust denial now? by Mira Fox [Forward]
SUPPORT THE TRANS AGENDA
Tired of the same old news narratives? Get ‘The Trans Agenda’ delivered right to your inbox – news with the trans community at the forefront. Subscribe now!
The Trans Agenda also needs your help. Your donation powers my reporting efforts, amplifying trans voices and keeps you in the know. Support independent trans journalism. Help keep in-depth reporting in ‘The Trans Agenda’ available and accessible by donating today!
CALL FOR STORIES
Seen something newsworthy related to the trans community in the UK? Send me a tip! I’m always looking for leads and underreported stories.