The Trans Agenda #25
[18 April 2024]
Welcome to The Trans Agenda, a newsletter that will arrive in your inbox Monday and Thursday if you are subscribed. You can also read it on Substack and on Trans Writes.
Publications known for taking an anti-trans stance are and will be referenced and linked. Often, these are the most comprehensive sources for these stories because of their obsession with trans people. I give a summary for those stories so you can make the choice if you want to click the link or seek out more information elsewhere.
As always, if you have any suggestions, I’m open to feedback and you can contact me using the links on this page near the bottom.
The Trans Agenda
NEWS & POLITICS
Study reveals decline in happiness among Scotland’s trans community [Pink News]
- A recent study reports a significant decline in happiness among Scotland’s transgender population. I wonder why that is…
Yousaf rejects closure of Glasgow’s NHS gender-services clinic [Guardian – see PAPERS section]
- Humza Yousaf, Scotland’s First Minister, has rejected demands to shut down the Sandyford clinic in Glasgow, which is Scotland’s only facility offering treatment to gender-questioning young people. This comes in response to the discredited Cass review commissioned by NHS England, which questioned the effectiveness of puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones for treating gender incongruence after it threw out all research showing how effective they were.Despite cross-party calls for action, Yousaf defended the clinic’s work, emphasising the professional autonomy of clinicians over politicians in medical decisions. The Sandyford not only caters to transgender healthcare but also provides essential services such as emergency contraception, abortion, and support for sexual assault victims. With around 1,100 young people on its waiting list for gender services, the clinic is a critical resource for vulnerable groups.
Trans women will be protected by Scotland’s misogyny law [BBC]
- Scotland’s First Minister Humza Yousaf confirmed that new misogyny laws will protect transgender women, emphasising that all affected by misogyny, regardless of biological sex, are included. This statement backs the Scottish government’s ongoing efforts to introduce a misogyny bill by 2026. Yousaf clarified that the law covers anyone perceived as a woman, addressing threats regardless of the victim’s actual gender identity. The Gender Critical Sex Realist Cult, as usual, have reacted with rage because they are unable to comprehend basic concepts.
Scottish Labour vow to implement the Cass review in full [Stats for Lefties]
- Deputy Leader and Health spokesperson Jackie Baillie, speaking on behalf of the Scottish Labour Party, said: “The findings of the Cass Review must be implemented in Scotland.”
Minister calls for ban on transgender athletes in female-only sports [various]
- Lucy Frazer, the Culture Secretary, has called for a ban on transgender athletes competing in female-only sporting events. In a recent article in the Mail, Frazer urged sports governing bodies to establish clear and unambiguous guidelines concerning gender identity in sports. This move, which represents the government’s most assertive stance to date on the issue, underscores her bigoted belief that biological differences should not be overlooked in competitive sports. She emphasized the need for an explicit policy framework to address and resolve ongoing disputes over the participation of trans athletes in female-exclusive competitions.A recent study into trans athletes in sport found that her concerns are mostly all in her head [Trans Agenda #24].
As you can see in the PAPERS section below, to highlight this ‘problem’ in the UK, the Daily Mail had to use a picture of Lia Thomas, a college athlete from the US. Thomas came to the world’s attention after she won a race. She also lost others, something the anti-trans crew will tell you is impossible. After all, their entire ‘logic’ behind banning trans women is that cis women would never win another medal ever again if trans women are allowed to compete, despite trans women being allowed to compete for decades at the top level without winning any medals.
Lib Dems ‘disappointed’ in Cass review [Lib Dems]
- Although short, this initial statement said, “We are very disappointed by the lack of evidence leading to a conclusion which infantilises autistic people and is undeniable transphobia towards young adults and people. The Gillick competency saves lives and should be protected, not just for trans people but all people. Everyone has medical rights which should be protected.“LGBT+ Liberal Democrats will continue to stand with trans people, young people, autistic people and women to defend their right to bodily and medical autonomy.”
Canadian doctors reject Cass [CBC]
- Canadian doctors are challenging the findings of the UK‘s Cass Review, which led to NHS England restricting puberty blockers for transgender youth to clinical research settings due to “a lack of high-quality research.” Contrarily, Canadian physicians say, correctly, that substantial evidence supports the efficacy of puberty blockers in managing gender dysphoria, despite the absence of randomised clinical trials. They compare the situation to other medical practices, like pregnancy care, where clinical trials are also impractical or unethical. Canadian medical professionals emphasise the broader benefits of these treatments in improving the mental health and quality of life for transgender youth, advocating for continued access based on existing evidence and clinical guidelines.
UK’s first trans judge steps down [Times Law]
- Britain’s first transgender judge, Victoria McCloud, was honoured warmly at the end of her final case last week. Tributes were read by lawyers from the specialist personal injury bar and LGBT groups as McCloud retired from the High Court bench after 18 years of service. McCloud has stepped down after telling The Times, “…that at times she has felt so threatened by ferocity around the debate over transgenderism [sic] that she was forced to hire a bodyguard.”
Manchester to unveil national trans monument [Pink News]
- Manchester is set to unveil an historic national monument dedicated to celebrating the resilience of transgender people. This landmark will serve as a symbol of recognition and respect for the trans community, commemorating our struggles and contributions to society.
Liz Truss’s anti-trans bill is back
- For the third time, Liz Truss will attempt to get a second reading of her anti-trans Health and Equality Acts (Amendment) Bill. After already being filibustered by ferrets [Trans Agenda #11] both the Conservative Party and Labour have been working to keep this bill from the floor. Expect the same to happen on Friday.What does Liz Truss’s anti-trans bill actually say? Find out here
SNIPPETS
- At PMQs, Rishi Sunak accused the SNP of ‘trying to lock up JK Rowling’.
- Dawn French has defended JK Rowling (read more in PAPERS below). So, that’s both French and Saunders, with Jennifer having come out as a TERF some time ago.
- Graham Linehan, on camera, actually said the words “One of the things Hitler [did], putting Jewish people into ghettos did was actually strengthened ties…” su. He also compared the Gender Critical Sex Realist Cult to Jewish people under the Nazis [source].
- Maya Forstater had a tweet restricted in the EU for ‘illegal or harmful speech’ [source].
Keep an eye out for
- Pressure being applied by the government, media and Gender Critical Sex Realist Cult on private clinics issuing puberty blockers and The FA to ban trans women from football.
MEDIA & PAPERS
BBC says omission of trans identity of murderer Scarlet Blake was breach of accuracy rules [Press Gazette]
- The BBC has acknowledged a breach of its accuracy standards for not initially disclosing that Scarlet Blake, a convicted murderer, was a trans woman despite having absolutely no reason to do so. This omission, later corrected, was deemed material to understanding the case even though it wasn’t. Gender Critical believers, including JK Rowling, argued against describing Blake using female pronouns and the BBC buckled.Blake being trans was irrelevant to the story until the cult made it relevant.
Kathleen Stock nominated for National Press Award [Times]
- A throwaway line in an article in Thursday’s Times that you can see below in the PAPERS section, it doesn’t mention what piece she is nominated for.
Dutch journalist calls out Telegraph [Marieke Kuypers]
- When the Telegraph ran an article with the headline “Belgium and Netherlands call for puberty blocker restrictions following Cass Review”, Kuypers took to Twitter to explain how this just wasn’t true. She said, “The Netherlands has not called for puberty blocker restrictions. Conservative Dutch politicians who have wanted trans care to be restricted already, took the opportunity the Cass review gave them to ask in bad faith for more “investigation”” before going on to give a lot more information. She concludes, “this headline is completely false and I don’t think there is a plausible good faith explanation for writing such a completely misleading and false headline.”
Fox host calls trans kids coerced gay kids [LGBTQ Nation]
- Fox news primetime host Jesse Watters has said that trans youth are merely gay children who were coerced into undergoing gender-affirming surgery.
Newsguard downgrades credibility scores for New York Times, GB News and Daily Star [Press Gazette]
- Newsguard has downgraded the credibility scores of The New York Times, GB News, and the Daily Star. This shift follows a review of criteria on handling the difference between news and opinion, among others.
Editors unite in bid to stop anti-SLAPP bill being ‘ultimately redundant’ [Press Gazette]
- Editors from major news outlets, including The Guardian, The Times, The Telegraph and The Daily Mail, are pushing for amendments to the anti-SLAPP bill to prevent it from being ineffective. They argue that the bill’s current reliance on a subjective test for determining SLAPP cases introduces uncertainty and could undermine legal protections intended to shield journalists from vexatious lawsuits. They advocate for an objective test and a clearer definition of public interest to strengthen the bill.
Google trials removal of California news sites in response to proposed ‘link tax’ [Press Gazette]
- Google is temporarily removing links to California news sites from its search results for some users. This is a test in response to proposed legislation that would require tech companies to pay news publishers for using their content.
THE PAPERS
Tuesday 16 April 2024 [Total: 16. Publications 4, positive 0, negative 15, neutral with negative intent 1, written by trans people 0]
The Guardian [0]
- There were no articles about trans people in Tuesday’s edition of The Guardian
The Times [6, written by trans people: 0, negative: 6, positive: 0]
![Stonewall urged to drop allegations against equality chief James Beal Campaigners have demanded that Stonewall withdraw its allegations against the Equality and Human Rights Commission chairwoman amid the fallout from the Cass Review. A group of gender critical activists, writing in The Times today, accused the LGBT lobby group of playing a “significant role” in a culture of fear around the debate over trans ideology. They said Stonewall could try to “fix the toxicity of the debate” by dropping its claims against Baroness Falkner of Mar- gravine, the chairwoman of the EHRC. The commission is under investigation by the Global Alliance of National Human Rights Institutions and could be stripped of its top-level UN accreditation. It came after groups, including Stonewall, complained to the alliance that Falkner had taken a “determinedly anti-trans stance” on conversion therapy. The review, led by Dr Hilary Cass, a former president of the Royal College of Paediatrics, said last week that doctors and psychologists must not be criminalised by a ban on conversion therapy, simply for exploring a child’s gender distress. In the letter, the campaigners, said: “[Falkner] is under investigation ... when she, just like Dr Cass, urged caution in legislating to ban ‘conversion therapy’. Stonewall should withdraw its complaint, apologise to Baroness Falkner and let the EHRC get on with its job.” The complaint to the alliance came after the EHRC advised the government on the protected characteristic of sex in the Equality Act 2010. It said transgender people could be legitimately excluded from single-sex services if the reasons were “justifiable and proportionate”. The alliance’s accreditation sub-committee decided to open a special review of the status of the EHRC at a meeting in Geneva on October 27. The human rights body had received complaints from civil society and human rights organisations, including 30 LGBT groups. Its review came despite an EHRC investigation into bullying claims against Falkner having been closed three days earlier. Stonewall accused her of a lack of commitment to protecting and progressing the rights of trans people. A spokesman said: “Stonewall was one of dozens of LGBTQ+, human rights and disability charities that submitted evidence to [the alliance] about the compliance of EHRC with the Paris Principles. [The alliance] ... made several clear recommendations ... for EHRC to strengthen its work to promote and protect the rights of LGBTI people ... in line with international human rights standards, and it is on the basis of a number of concerns that this investigation has been launched.” Hospital flies flag for 21 sexualities Patients have criticised an NHS hospital over its welcome banner, which has the flags of 21 sexualities and gender identities (Poppy Koronka writes). The banner outside Royal Stoke University Hospital, in Stoke-on- Trent, says “everyone is welcome here” and has the 21 flags below it. It is understood that it was put up before Pride month last June to show support for LGBTQ+ NHS workers. One patient told The Sun: “People are waiting months and even years for treatment but the NHS is more interested in woke pandering.” The hospital declared a critical incident in February because of an “extremely high demand for services”. Jane Haire, the chief people officer at University Hospitals of North Midlands NHS Trust, said the banner “symbolises our commitment to achieving a more inclusive organisation where both colleagues and the people we care for are encouraged to be themselves”. Last May NHS England was criticised for listing 18 gender options on a patient form, which included “two-spirit”, a term used in indigenous communities, and “third gender”. 1 Rainbow The Gay Pride flag, launched in 1978 2 Progress Rainbow flag incorporating trans and ethnic minority people 3 Bisexual Attracted to both men and women 4 Pansexual Attracted to all genders 5 Nonbinary Does not identify as male or female 6 Transgender Identifies as different gender to their birth sex 7 Asexual Does not feel sexual attraction 8 Intersex Has male and female biological traits 9 Gay men Attracted to other men 10 Lesbian Attracted to other women 11 Polysexual Attracted to more than one gender 12 Agender Does not identify with a gender 13 Androgyne Appearance is neither masculine nor feminine 14 Genderfluid Feels their gender is changeable 15 Genderqueer Does not subscribe to or follow binary gender norms 16 Neutrois Has a gender identity but it is neither masculine nor feminine 17 Aromantic Has little or no romantic feeling 18 Demisexual Sexually attracted only after being emotionally close 19 Demiromantic Romantically attracted only after becoming emotionally close 20 Polyamorous Multiple relationships at once 21 Straight ally Heterosexual but supports the LGBTQ+ community. Private doctors who give children puberty blockers may be struck off Chris Smyth - Whitehall Editor, James Beal - Social Affairs Editor Doctors who prescribe puberty blockers to children privately risk being struck off, the health secretary has said as she insisted that “fashionable cultural values” must no longer be allowed to dominate gender medicine. Victoria Atkins said that private clinics which ignore an NHS review and carry on prescribing hormones to under-16s face being shut down, adding that she was ready to change the law to block doctors from issuing prescriptions from overseas. Last week a review led by Dr Hilary Cass concluded that the field of gender medicine was built on “shaky foundations”, with no good evidence to support the widespread practice of prescribing hormones to under-18s to delay puberty. The NHS has now advised against prescribing puberty blockers to under-18s as Cass said that medical treatment would not be the best option for most young people. Atkins told MPs she would “work with NHS England to root out the ideology that has caused so much unnecessary harm” in a pugnacious Commons appearance, demanding opposition MPs apologise for past comments condemning gender critical stances. She said that Cass’s review “strikes hard and strikes sure at an area of public policy where fashionable cultural values have overtaken evidence, safety and biological reality. This must now stop.” The Tavistock child gender clinic at the heart of the review has been accused of providing “very little” paperwork to lawyers representing former patients looking to sue for medical negligence. Lawyers say that they are talking to “dozens” of former patients of the gender identity development service at the Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust about potential claims. A huge rise in teenage girls presenting to England’s only specialist gender clinic was “driven by myth”, Atkins said. “This myth was that for children and young people grappling with adolescence, who were questioning their identity, their sexuality, or their path in life, that the answer to their questions was inevitably to change gender to solve their feelings of unease, discomfort, or distress. We have to get away from this idea that if a child presents with gender distress that is the only part of their health that we care about.” She criticised Tavistock doctors for thinking that the right solution “was almost always to put [children] on an irreversible path, blocking puberty, then the prescription of cross-sex hormones, and on to surgery as an adult”, saying such professionals were not asking the right questions of themselves, or of their patients. Parents were “let down by a service that vilified them for questioning whether the interventions offered were the right ones for their children”. Cass last week said she was concerned that some private clinics were not following guidance she had set out for the NHS and Atkins yesterday gave them “a very clear warning”. She said: “The Care Quality Commission has not licensed any gender clinic to prescribe hormone blockers or cross-sex hormones to people under the age of 16. Any clinic that does may be committing serious regulatory offences, for which they can have their licence revoked and their clinicians can be struck off.” The CQC, which regulates clinics, has agreed to inspect services against Cass’s standards while officials are asking the General Medical Council “how they will ensure every clinician on their register follows their code of practice”, Atkins said. Wes Streeting, the shadow health secretary, said that Cass had exposed a scandal and that “even in this, a general election year, there is surely one issue on which we can down tools and work together and that is in pursuit of the health care of vulnerable people”. Lisa Lunt, a partner at Pogust Goodhead, a law firm assessing claims against the clinic, has put in a letter of claim to its solicitors for medical negligence on behalf of a former Tavistock patient who has now de-transitioned. Stonewall urged to drop allegations against equality chief James Beal Campaigners have demanded that Stonewall withdraw its allegations against the Equality and Human Rights Commission chairwoman amid the fallout from the Cass Review. A group of gender critical activists, writing in The Times today, accused the LGBT lobby group of playing a “significant role” in a culture of fear around the debate over trans ideology. They said Stonewall could try to “fix the toxicity of the debate” by dropping its claims against Baroness Falkner of Mar- gravine, the chairwoman of the EHRC. The commission is under investigation by the Global Alliance of National Human Rights Institutions and could be stripped of its top-level UN accreditation. It came after groups, including Stonewall, complained to the alliance that Falkner had taken a “determinedly anti-trans stance” on conversion therapy. The review, led by Dr Hilary Cass, a former president of the Royal College of Paediatrics, said last week that doctors and psychologists must not be criminalised by a ban on conversion therapy, simply for exploring a child’s gender distress. In the letter, the campaigners, said: “[Falkner] is under investigation ... when she, just like Dr Cass, urged caution in legislating to ban ‘conversion therapy’. Stonewall should withdraw its complaint, apologise to Baroness Falkner and let the EHRC get on with its job.” The complaint to the alliance came after the EHRC advised the government on the protected characteristic of sex in the Equality Act 2010. It said transgender people could be legitimately excluded from single-sex services if the reasons were “justifiable and proportionate”. The alliance’s accreditation sub-committee decided to open a special review of the status of the EHRC at a meeting in Geneva on October 27. The human rights body had received complaints from civil society and human rights organisations, including 30 LGBT groups. Its review came despite an EHRC investigation into bullying claims against Falkner having been closed three days earlier. Stonewall accused her of a lack of commitment to protecting and progressing the rights of trans people. A spokesman said: “Stonewall was one of dozens of LGBTQ+, human rights and disability charities that submitted evidence to [the alliance] about the compliance of EHRC with the Paris Principles. [The alliance] ... made several clear recommendations ... for EHRC to strengthen its work to promote and protect the rights of LGBTI people ... in line with international human rights standards, and it is on the basis of a number of concerns that this investigation has been launched.” Hospital flies flag for 21 sexualities Patients have criticised an NHS hospital over its welcome banner, which has the flags of 21 sexualities and gender identities (Poppy Koronka writes). The banner outside Royal Stoke University Hospital, in Stoke-on- Trent, says “everyone is welcome here” and has the 21 flags below it. It is understood that it was put up before Pride month last June to show support for LGBTQ+ NHS workers. One patient told The Sun: “People are waiting months and even years for treatment but the NHS is more interested in woke pandering.” The hospital declared a critical incident in February because of an “extremely high demand for services”. Jane Haire, the chief people officer at University Hospitals of North Midlands NHS Trust, said the banner “symbolises our commitment to achieving a more inclusive organisation where both colleagues and the people we care for are encouraged to be themselves”. Last May NHS England was criticised for listing 18 gender options on a patient form, which included “two-spirit”, a term used in indigenous communities, and “third gender”. 1 Rainbow The Gay Pride flag, launched in 1978 2 Progress Rainbow flag incorporating trans and ethnic minority people 3 Bisexual Attracted to both men and women 4 Pansexual Attracted to all genders 5 Nonbinary Does not identify as male or female 6 Transgender Identifies as different gender to their birth sex 7 Asexual Does not feel sexual attraction 8 Intersex Has male and female biological traits 9 Gay men Attracted to other men 10 Lesbian Attracted to other women 11 Polysexual Attracted to more than one gender 12 Agender Does not identify with a gender 13 Androgyne Appearance is neither masculine nor feminine 14 Genderfluid Feels their gender is changeable 15 Genderqueer Does not subscribe to or follow binary gender norms 16 Neutrois Has a gender identity but it is neither masculine nor feminine 17 Aromantic Has little or no romantic feeling 18 Demisexual Sexually attracted only after being emotionally close 19 Demiromantic Romantically attracted only after becoming emotionally close 20 Polyamorous Multiple relationships at once 21 Straight ally Heterosexual but supports the LGBTQ+ community. Private doctors who give children puberty blockers may be struck off Chris Smyth - Whitehall Editor, James Beal - Social Affairs Editor Doctors who prescribe puberty blockers to children privately risk being struck off, the health secretary has said as she insisted that “fashionable cultural values” must no longer be allowed to dominate gender medicine. Victoria Atkins said that private clinics which ignore an NHS review and carry on prescribing hormones to under-16s face being shut down, adding that she was ready to change the law to block doctors from issuing prescriptions from overseas. Last week a review led by Dr Hilary Cass concluded that the field of gender medicine was built on “shaky foundations”, with no good evidence to support the widespread practice of prescribing hormones to under-18s to delay puberty. The NHS has now advised against prescribing puberty blockers to under-18s as Cass said that medical treatment would not be the best option for most young people. Atkins told MPs she would “work with NHS England to root out the ideology that has caused so much unnecessary harm” in a pugnacious Commons appearance, demanding opposition MPs apologise for past comments condemning gender critical stances. She said that Cass’s review “strikes hard and strikes sure at an area of public policy where fashionable cultural values have overtaken evidence, safety and biological reality. This must now stop.” The Tavistock child gender clinic at the heart of the review has been accused of providing “very little” paperwork to lawyers representing former patients looking to sue for medical negligence. Lawyers say that they are talking to “dozens” of former patients of the gender identity development service at the Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust about potential claims. A huge rise in teenage girls presenting to England’s only specialist gender clinic was “driven by myth”, Atkins said. “This myth was that for children and young people grappling with adolescence, who were questioning their identity, their sexuality, or their path in life, that the answer to their questions was inevitably to change gender to solve their feelings of unease, discomfort, or distress. We have to get away from this idea that if a child presents with gender distress that is the only part of their health that we care about.” She criticised Tavistock doctors for thinking that the right solution “was almost always to put [children] on an irreversible path, blocking puberty, then the prescription of cross-sex hormones, and on to surgery as an adult”, saying such professionals were not asking the right questions of themselves, or of their patients. Parents were “let down by a service that vilified them for questioning whether the interventions offered were the right ones for their children”. Cass last week said she was concerned that some private clinics were not following guidance she had set out for the NHS and Atkins yesterday gave them “a very clear warning”. She said: “The Care Quality Commission has not licensed any gender clinic to prescribe hormone blockers or cross-sex hormones to people under the age of 16. Any clinic that does may be committing serious regulatory offences, for which they can have their licence revoked and their clinicians can be struck off.” The CQC, which regulates clinics, has agreed to inspect services against Cass’s standards while officials are asking the General Medical Council “how they will ensure every clinician on their register follows their code of practice”, Atkins said. Wes Streeting, the shadow health secretary, said that Cass had exposed a scandal and that “even in this, a general election year, there is surely one issue on which we can down tools and work together and that is in pursuit of the health care of vulnerable people”. Lisa Lunt, a partner at Pogust Goodhead, a law firm assessing claims against the clinic, has put in a letter of claim to its solicitors for medical negligence on behalf of a former Tavistock patient who has now de-transitioned.](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F23f04fc3-ffb8-4f7a-9036-3ef56ddc19fe_661x848.jpeg)
![Dawn French: I can smell my cowardice in the culture wars Lara Wildenberg The comedian was told to “catch up” by a podcast host Dawn French has criticised cancel culture and defended JK Rowling after being told that she needed to “catch up” on transgender rights. The actress and comedian, 66, known for French and Saunders as well as The Vicar of Dibley, described the Harry Potter author as someone who had “made her mistakes but is also a good person”. Speaking to Fearne Cotton on her Happy Place podcast, French said that Rowling had “paid a huge price” and that robust debate was needed in the discussion of gender identity. “I genuinely think we’re being forced into corners where I can smell my own cowardice. I don’t like that — I’ve never been cowardly, I hope, but I’m starting to be that because I’m being circumspect about what I will support or not in case it causes trouble”. She added: “As women especially — that’s the last thing we should do is shut up.” She said she loved the idea of favouring difference and praised the power of saying “I don’t know” in culture wars. French was prompted to criticise such binary thinking after a recent discussion about Rowling’s gender-critical language. She said she had been reprimanded by another podcast host for asking why terminology used by the Harry Potter star was considered unacceptable. [She said] the podcast host had told her: “You need to catch up — people can’t be constantly teaching you how to be because this is not OK; you need to catch up.” Last week, Rowling, who French claimed to “know a bit”, condemned celebrities who “used their platforms to cheer on” the transitioning of children. Dawn French: I can smell my cowardice in the culture wars Lara Wildenberg The comedian was told to “catch up” by a podcast host Dawn French has criticised cancel culture and defended JK Rowling after being told that she needed to “catch up” on transgender rights. The actress and comedian, 66, known for French and Saunders as well as The Vicar of Dibley, described the Harry Potter author as someone who had “made her mistakes but is also a good person”. Speaking to Fearne Cotton on her Happy Place podcast, French said that Rowling had “paid a huge price” and that robust debate was needed in the discussion of gender identity. “I genuinely think we’re being forced into corners where I can smell my own cowardice. I don’t like that — I’ve never been cowardly, I hope, but I’m starting to be that because I’m being circumspect about what I will support or not in case it causes trouble”. She added: “As women especially — that’s the last thing we should do is shut up.” She said she loved the idea of favouring difference and praised the power of saying “I don’t know” in culture wars. French was prompted to criticise such binary thinking after a recent discussion about Rowling’s gender-critical language. She said she had been reprimanded by another podcast host for asking why terminology used by the Harry Potter star was considered unacceptable. [She said] the podcast host had told her: “You need to catch up — people can’t be constantly teaching you how to be because this is not OK; you need to catch up.” Last week, Rowling, who French claimed to “know a bit”, condemned celebrities who “used their platforms to cheer on” the transitioning of children.](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fdba43591-e0ec-4086-a237-89eb0fb58ac6_606x636.jpeg)



Daily Mail [6, written by trans people: 0, negative: 6, positive: 0]





Telegraph [4, written by trans people: 0, negative: 3, positive: 0, neutral with negative intent: 1]




Wednesday 17 April 2024 [Total: Publications 4, positive 0, negative 8, neutral 1, written by trans people 0]
The Guardian [2, written by trans people: 0, negative: 1, positive: 0, neutral: 1]
![Yousaf rejects calls to close NHS gender-services clinic in Glasgow The Guardian17 Apr 2024Libby Brooks Scotland correspondent There is no case for closing Scotland’s only clinic to offer treatment to gender-questioning young people, Humza Yousaf has said, amid calls to halt the service in response to the Cass review. The Sandyford clinic, based in Glasgow, offers a range of services including emergency contraception, abortion and support for sexual assault victims as well as transgender healthcare. This includes the Young People’s Gender Service that can refer under-18s to endocrine specialists for possible prescription of puberty blockers. About 1,100 young people are on the waiting list. Last week, a landmark review by the paediatrician Dr Hilary Cass that was commissioned by NHS England found “weak evidence” for the use of puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones to treat young people experiencing gender incongruence and said that this vulnerable cohort had been “let down” by the “toxicity” of the debate surrounding their care. Speaking to BBC Radio Scotland as the Holyrood parliament resumed after Easter recess, Yousaf said Scottish health boards would give the “utmost consideration” to Cass’s 388page report. But he added: “When it comes to the prescribing of medicine, clinicians are best placed – not politicians, government ministers or myself as first minister.” Yousaf said: “I don’t believe that there’s a case to close the Sandyford. The Sandyford provides some exceptional healthcare to some of those who are the most marginalised and vulnerable, not just young people, but right across the spectrum.” The Scottish government is facing cross-party pressure to respond to the review. The Scottish Labour leader, Anas Sarwar, on Monday called for the Scottish government “to quickly come forward and [say] how they’re going to respond”. The Scottish Tory deputy leader, Meghan Gallacher, accused Yousaf of “failing vulnerable young people” and called for him to pause the prescribing of puberty blockers while clinicians considered the report. The Cass review found there was no evidence that puberty blockers affected gender dysphoria but that they did compromise bone health and that they should only be offered in very limited circumstances as part of a wider research protocol. But on Monday, Holyrood’s minister for mental wellbeing, Maree Todd, said puberty blockers “were never routinely prescribed” in Scotland. It is understood that “a very small number” of under-18s have been referred by the Sandyford to endocrinology for puberty blockers in the last 12 months but that, given the numbers involved and patient confidentiality, the health board cannot disclose the exact figure. Clinicians at the Sandyford have previously told the Guardian that a referral there often allows confused young people, and anxious parents, the chance to reflect on what is really troubling them with a variety of professionals, who can often “inject a sense of reality” to believing that what patients have read online could be a quick fix for their problems. While critics have described the clinic as “the tartan Tavistock” (the London clinic that was closed after it was criticised in an independent review), the Guardian understands that the Sandyford does not follow a strictly affirmative model of care for young people, an approach that Cass called into question. Staff have also described the pressure of ongoing anti-abortion protests outside the clinic. Last year, members of the Scottish Family party carried out a mock “bricking up” of the entrance to the clinic. A spokesperson for NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde said: “We are committed to providing the best possible clinical care for young people accessing our gender services. We are working with the Scottish government and NHS Scotland to consider the findings of this review.” Article Name:Yousaf rejects calls to close NHS gender-services clinic in Glasgow Publication:The Guardian Author:Libby Brooks Scotland correspondent Start Page:17 End Page:17 Yousaf rejects calls to close NHS gender-services clinic in Glasgow The Guardian17 Apr 2024Libby Brooks Scotland correspondent There is no case for closing Scotland’s only clinic to offer treatment to gender-questioning young people, Humza Yousaf has said, amid calls to halt the service in response to the Cass review. The Sandyford clinic, based in Glasgow, offers a range of services including emergency contraception, abortion and support for sexual assault victims as well as transgender healthcare. This includes the Young People’s Gender Service that can refer under-18s to endocrine specialists for possible prescription of puberty blockers. About 1,100 young people are on the waiting list. Last week, a landmark review by the paediatrician Dr Hilary Cass that was commissioned by NHS England found “weak evidence” for the use of puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones to treat young people experiencing gender incongruence and said that this vulnerable cohort had been “let down” by the “toxicity” of the debate surrounding their care. Speaking to BBC Radio Scotland as the Holyrood parliament resumed after Easter recess, Yousaf said Scottish health boards would give the “utmost consideration” to Cass’s 388page report. But he added: “When it comes to the prescribing of medicine, clinicians are best placed – not politicians, government ministers or myself as first minister.” Yousaf said: “I don’t believe that there’s a case to close the Sandyford. The Sandyford provides some exceptional healthcare to some of those who are the most marginalised and vulnerable, not just young people, but right across the spectrum.” The Scottish government is facing cross-party pressure to respond to the review. The Scottish Labour leader, Anas Sarwar, on Monday called for the Scottish government “to quickly come forward and [say] how they’re going to respond”. The Scottish Tory deputy leader, Meghan Gallacher, accused Yousaf of “failing vulnerable young people” and called for him to pause the prescribing of puberty blockers while clinicians considered the report. The Cass review found there was no evidence that puberty blockers affected gender dysphoria but that they did compromise bone health and that they should only be offered in very limited circumstances as part of a wider research protocol. But on Monday, Holyrood’s minister for mental wellbeing, Maree Todd, said puberty blockers “were never routinely prescribed” in Scotland. It is understood that “a very small number” of under-18s have been referred by the Sandyford to endocrinology for puberty blockers in the last 12 months but that, given the numbers involved and patient confidentiality, the health board cannot disclose the exact figure. Clinicians at the Sandyford have previously told the Guardian that a referral there often allows confused young people, and anxious parents, the chance to reflect on what is really troubling them with a variety of professionals, who can often “inject a sense of reality” to believing that what patients have read online could be a quick fix for their problems. While critics have described the clinic as “the tartan Tavistock” (the London clinic that was closed after it was criticised in an independent review), the Guardian understands that the Sandyford does not follow a strictly affirmative model of care for young people, an approach that Cass called into question. Staff have also described the pressure of ongoing anti-abortion protests outside the clinic. Last year, members of the Scottish Family party carried out a mock “bricking up” of the entrance to the clinic. A spokesperson for NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde said: “We are committed to providing the best possible clinical care for young people accessing our gender services. We are working with the Scottish government and NHS Scotland to consider the findings of this review.” Article Name:Yousaf rejects calls to close NHS gender-services clinic in Glasgow Publication:The Guardian Author:Libby Brooks Scotland correspondent Start Page:17 End Page:17](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Feefef1ad-580b-44cb-9e89-524638780390_1177x552.jpeg)
The Times [2, written by trans people: 0, negative: 2, positive: 0]


Daily Mail [2, written by trans people: 0, negative: 2, positive: 0]


Telegraph [3, written by trans people: 0, negative: 3, positive: 0]



Thursday 17 April 2024 [Total: Publications 4, positive 6, negative 0, neutral 1, written by trans people 0]
The Guardian [1, written by trans people: 0, negative: 0, positive: 0, neutral: 1]

The Times [2, written by trans people: 0, negative: 2, positive: 0]


Daily Mail [2, written by trans people: 0, negative: 2, positive: 0]


Telegraph [2, written by trans people: 0, negative: 2, positive: 0]



THIS WEEK IN PARLIAMENT
House of Commons
- Thursday 18 April 2024
- No business that fits the concerns of this newsletter
- Friday 19 April 2024
- Private Members’ Bills inc:
- Autism (Early Identification) Bill: Second Reading
- Liz Truss’s Health and Equality Acts (Amendment) Bill: Second Reading
- Private Members’ Bills inc:
Westminster Hall
- Thursday 18 April 2024
- No business that fits the concerns of this newsletter
- Friday 19 April 2024
- No business today
House of Lords
- Thursday 18 April 2024
- Debate – Long-term sustainability of the NHS and delivery of comprehensive, timely and affordable health care [more details here]
- Debate – Number of children and young people being committed into the care of local authorities [more details here]
- Friday 19 April 2024
- Debates – None of which fit the concerns of this newsletter
Committees
- Thursday 18 April 2024
- No business that fits the concerns of this newsletter
- Friday 19 April 2024
- No committees are meeting today
AROUND THE WORLD
Sweden’s parliament passes a law to make it easier for young people to legally change their gender [AP]
- Sweden‘s parliament has passed a law lowering the legal age for gender change from 18 to 16. Minors still require approval from a guardian, a doctor, and the National Board of Health and Welfare. The law, which also removes the need for a gender dysphoria diagnosis, aligns Sweden with countries like Denmark and Norway in supporting transgender rights.
Bomb threats at Planet Fitness linked to ‘Libs of TikTok’ [The Guardian]
- Planet Fitness locations across the U.S. have received bomb threats after being targeted by the ‘Libs of TikTok’ account, which accused the gym chain of allowing men into women’s locker rooms.
West Virginia court overturns transgender care ban [The Advocate]
- A court in West Virginia has successfully overturned a ban on transgender care, marking a significant legal win for transgender rights in the state.
Appeals court overturns West Virginia’s transgender sports ban [LGBTQ Nation]
- An appeals court has overturned West Virginia‘s ban on trans athletes participating in sports that match their gender identity.
Ohio court blocks transgender care law [The Advocate]
- In Ohio, a recent court decision has blocked the enforcement of a law that restricted transgender care, safeguarding healthcare access for transgender people.
Idaho’s trans care ban remains unenforced [The Advocate]
- Idaho‘s ban on transgender care continues to go unenforced, following judicial interventions. The state’s attempts to restrict healthcare access for transgender people have not taken effect, allowing for the continued provision of necessary medical treatments.
Judge supports Letitia James in defending transgender athletes [LGBTQ Nation]
- A judge has dismissed a lawsuit that tried to prevent New York Attorney General Letitia James from defending the rights of transgender athletes.
Kentucky’s anti-LGBTQ bills fail to pass [LGBTQ Nation]
- All proposed anti-LGBTQ bills in Kentucky have failed to pass.
Transgender individuals in Florida face harassment under bathroom law [LGBTQ Nation]
- Trans people in Florida are resorting to extreme measures like avoiding water and using bottles to urinate due to harassment stemming from the state’s bathroom law.
Maine lawmakers advance bill to protect gender-affirming care despite threats [LGBTQ Nation]
- In Maine, lawmakers are advancing a bill to protect gender-affirming care for trans people, despite facing death threats.
Right-wing snowflakes complain of unfair advantage for trans women in eating contests [LGBTQ Nation]
- Right-wing commentators have claimed that trans women have an unfair advantage in hot dog eating contests.
Family discusses challenges and support for transgender child in Moldova [Global Voices.]
- In Moldova, the family of a transgender child shares their journey of navigating societal challenges and finding support within their community. They discuss the difficulties in accessing proper healthcare and education, as well as the social stigma they face.
ANY OTHER BUSINESS
Guide to major Pride events in 2024 [The Gay UK]
- The Gay UK has published a comprehensive guide to all major Pride events scheduled for 2024 around the world. The guide includes dates and locations for festivals and parades providing a valuable resource for those looking to participate in or support Pride activities.
Misconduct proven against former officer [Met Police]
- A former officer who acted inappropriately towards a female colleague has had misconduct proven against him.
Italy’s prime minister condemns surrogacy [The Advocate]
- Italy’s Prime Minister has publicly condemned the practice of surrogacy, aligning with conservative viewpoints in the country.
RECOMMENDED READING
- Spare a Thought for Hilary Cass, few have dared to fail so publicly, by Gemma Stone for Novara Media.
TRANSWRITES YOU MIGHT HAVE MISSED
- The 32 things The Cass Review recommends and why they are concerning, by Gemma Stone.
- NHS & puberty blockers: Former GIDS patients reflect on long wait times, invasive assessments, by Sasha Baker.
- What does Liz Truss’s anti-trans bill actually say? By Lee Hurley.
- The Cass Review: A government-sanctioned attack on trans lives, by Lee Hurley.
SUPPORT THE TRANS AGENDA
Tired of the same old news narratives? Get ‘The Trans Agenda’ delivered right to your inbox – news with the trans community at the forefront. Subscribe now!
The Trans Agenda also needs your help. Your donation powers my reporting efforts, amplifying trans voices and keeps you in the know. Support independent trans journalism. Help keep in-depth reporting in ‘The Trans Agenda’ available and accessible by donating today!
CALL FOR STORIES
Seen something newsworthy related to the trans community in the UK? Send me a tip! I’m always looking for leads and underreported stories.